|
Voice as a Primary Tool of Trade
Just as a hammer or saw is crucial to a carpenter, voice is a primary
tool of trade for many American workers. Imagine how difficult it
would be to communicate with suppliers, coworkers or customers without
the use of the voice. At least one in four of all working Americans
would find it impossible to pursue their professions of choice, while
others may even put public safety at risk should their voices become
disabled.
Dr. Ingo Titze and his colleagues at the National
Center for Voice and Speech explored three areas relating jobs
and voice use.
- what jobs are most
often represented among the clients at voice centers?
- how many working Americans
may be classified as professional voice users? and
- what percentage of the U.S.
workforce needs healthy voices to ensure public safety?
Voice
Professionals seen in Clinics
At least four studies have identified professions
most often represented among people who seek help at voice centers.
The investigators tallied clients' jobs at voice centers in Iowa,
Ohio, Utah, Wisconsin and Sweden.
In three of the four studies, teachers were
identified as the professional group most frequently treated
for voice problems. Other occupations often represented
include: retired persons (previous profession unknown), entertainers
(singers and actors), factory workers or machine operators,
managers, clerical workers, and sales personnel.
Voice Professionals as a Percentage
of the Workforce
In another investigation, Dr. Titze and his colleagues categorized
U.S. workers by occupation using figures from the U.S. Bureau of
Labor Statistics and professional organizations. To maintain consistency,
all numbers were based upon 1994 statistics using a total of 123,060,000
U.S. workers. Once the entire labor pool was divided into career
categories, professions requiring voice use were identified. Discussions
of several occupational groups are presented below.
It is interesting to compare the percentage of
Americans within a career category with its representation at
voice centers. If the representation at voice centers is higher,
it may mean that the job is vocally demanding. Thus, workers
within this job group may be at higher "vocal risk" as compared
to other professionals.
Salespeople compose about 13 percent of
the U.S. workforce; in general, their appearance in voice centers
is about equal to their workforce percentage. However, those
in telephone sales constitute 0.78 percent of the U.S. workforce,
but make up 2.3 percent of the clinic load. Thus, within the
professional group of salespeople, telemarketers may be at the
most severe vocal risk.
Teachers represent 4.2 percent of the U.S.
workforce. However, this group constitutes almost 20 percent
of the voice-clinic load, a five-fold disproportion Dr. Titze
calls "quite remarkable."
Receptionists and public relations workers make
up slightly less than 1 percent of the U.S. workforce. It is
unknown what fraction of clinic load they represent; Dr. Titze
estimates it is 3-4 percent.
Lawyers and judges who regularly speak
in court are only about 0.1 percent of the U.S. workforce. Unfortunately,
information about their appearance at voice centers is currently
unknown.
Clergy, psychologists, counselors and speech-language
pathologists compose 0.8 percent of the total U.S. workforce.
While all subgroups in this category couldn't be compared to
the voice clinic data, it is known that counselors constitute
only about 0.2 percent of the workforce, but are 1.6 percent
of the voice center clientele.
Telephone operators make up 0.13 percent
of the workforce and are 0.4 percent of the clinical voice load.
Interviewers/recruiters are about 0.13
percent of working Americans; specific clinic-load data is not
available.
Actors, directors, broadcasters and singers are
a difficult group to enumerate. Many individuals in this group
pursue entertainment on a part-time or hobby basis. However,
an interesting subgroup was singers, which was estimated as 0.02
percent of the workforce, while the sampled clinic load was 11.5
percent.
The table below summarizes several comparisons.
Occupation,
ages 16 and older |
Percent of working
US population |
Percent of
clinic load |
| Factory workers |
14.53 |
5.6 |
| Salespeople |
12.97 |
10.3 |
| Clerical workers |
10.57 |
8.6 |
| Teachers |
4.2 |
19.6 |
| Counselors |
0.19 |
1.6 |
| Singers |
0.02 |
11.5 |
Voice and Public Safety
Finally, professionals whose vocal well-being impacts on public safety
were tallied. This group includes: the military, police officers,
construction supervisors, dispatchers, firefighters, pilots and air
traffic controllers. These professionals as a group make up about
3 percent of the U.S. workforce. While this group is somewhat small,
the ability of these professionals to use their voices reliably has
the potential of literally saving lives.
This study is just the beginning of many possible
investigations relating vocal capability to the vocal demands
of various professions. How loudly and how frequently professionals
use their voices are other important factors for prevention of
disorders. This information, a logical next area of investigation,
can help speech-language pathologists and voice educators better
understand the professional demands of their clientele.
A full treatment of this investigation is published in Titze, I.,
Lemke, J., Montequin, D. Populations in the U.S. Workforce Who Rely
on Voice as a Primary Tool of Trade: A Preliminary Report. The
Journal of Voice 11(3), 254-259.
Back
to Information for Lifelong Learners
|